Should I Take First Offer of a Car Accident Settlement?

Every case is unique — but you deserve to know what factors truly affect your claim's value.
5 stars
300+ 5-Star Reviews
The National TOP 40 UNDER 40 trial lawyersThe Lawyers of Distinction Reader's Choice AwardsRising Stars by Super Lawyers

When a person is involved in an accident, many things rush through their mind. How will I pay my bills? I’m going to need money to get to and from doctor’s appointments. I need help paying these medical bills. This experience is a highly stressful and confusing time for an accident victim.

Insurance Company: Initial Offer

An insurance company is a business. They are out to make money, not lose money. When an accident claim comes across their desk, they immediately check into it.

Their job is to keep the other party from filing a lawsuit. They know that the victim will most likely pursue a lawsuit to get fairly compensated. Insurance companies do not want this. They stand to lose a lot of money if the injured person hires a highly-skilled, reputable lawyer.

The insurance companies offer quick cash to avoid full payouts. Signing an agreement with an insurance company will stop any future legal claim for injuries or damage. Unfortunately, countless people fall suspect to this insurance company strategy.

Example: Following an accident, the victim is injured and stressed out, wondering how they’ll cover their bills when they can’t work. The insurance company calls and pretends to answer their worries. They offer a small amount, such as $3,000 “to pay their bills and get on with their life.” Unfortunately, the victim’s doctor later states that the victim will miss more work than originally expected, and their injuries are more severe than originally thought. Their bills top $40,000.

The $3,000 will not help nearly enough. The victim realizes they must find the money to pay for their medical bills and ongoing living expenses while they’re out of work.

Now they decide to contact a lawyer. However, it is too late. By signing the insurance papers to collect the $3,000, they gave up any right to pursue other legal action against the at-fault party.

Consider This Before Accepting an Offer

Injuries are usually simple to calculate as far as medical expenses. You can look at the medical bills and see the expenses for medical treatment and hospital stays. Yet, not all injuries are visible right away, and other potential damages are less obvious.

In Texas, you may pursue other non-economic damages, including:

  • Pain and suffering
  • Emotional distress
  • Lost companionship
  • Lost future earning capacity

Insurance Companies Do Not Want to Go to Court

Insurance companies want to avoid going to court, and they will fight to keep the matter from going before a judge.

Here is an example:

You hire an attorney. The lawyer adds up all the medical bills and potential non-economic damages and then approaches the insurance company. The insurance company does not want to pay that amount. Instead, they tell the attorney they will only pay half.

The attorney refuses, as the actual damages are much higher. There is no agreement, so, the parties go to trial.

Everything gets brought up in court, and the jury decides that the insurance company owes double what the victim’s accident lawyer asked.

Because the insurance company failed to agree to an appropriate amount, they must now pay more.

This scenario happens often. Insurance companies know that if they go to court, they may pay the victim much more money. This reason incentivizes them to settle out of court when possible.

Insurance Company Scare Tactics

When an insurance company approaches an accident victim with the initial offer, they will often tell the victim that this is the maximum compensation possible. The insurance company will have a dollar amount in mind as the highest they want to pay. They will never approach a person with this number because they expect you to negotiate.

Accident victims should seek the advice of a personal injury attorney to maximize their potential monetary recovery. Never talk to the insurance companies directly. This step is where your lawyer comes in. While you focus on your health and physical recovery, your lawyer will aggressively fight for your fair compensation.
If you want to pursue legal action after your accident, contact a car accident lawyer today to discuss your case. Only worry about getting back to your normal activities and lifestyle. Your car accident lawyer can answer your questions and take care of the insurance companies for you.

A Brownsville Car Accident Lawyer
Answers Your Questions

Ask a Question

Let our experience, resources, and commitment to the Rio Grande Valley community work for you.

Get Your Free Consultation Now 956-544-9292

We're available 24/7 for urgent matters.

The timeline varies significantly depending on the complexity of your case, the severity of your injuries, how long your medical treatment takes, and whether the case settles through negotiation or goes to trial. Some cases resolve in a few months, while others can take a year or more.

Yes, under Texas's modified comparative fault rule, you can still recover damages even if you were partially at fault, as long as your fault is determined to be 50% or less. Your settlement amount would be reduced by your percentage of fault.

A settlement is an agreement reached between the injured party and the at-fault party (or their insurance company) outside of court. A verdict is the decision reached by a judge or jury after a case goes to trial.

Generally, compensation received for physical injuries and sickness in a personal injury settlement is not taxable by the IRS. However, punitive damages or compensation for lost wages (depending on how it's categorized) might be. It's always best to consult with a tax professional.

A lawyer helps you get a higher settlement by accurately valuing all your damages (including future medical needs and pain and suffering), gathering strong evidence, proving liability, handling all communications and negotiations with insurance companies, and being prepared to take your case to court if a fair settlement is not offered.

The Kenny Perez Law Difference

At Kenny Perez Law, we bring all of these qualities to every personal injury case we handle. Our deep roots in the Rio Grande Valley community, combined with our proven record of success, make us the right choice for injury victims throughout Brownsville and surrounding areas.

  • Personal attention: You'll work directly with experienced attorneys, not paralegals or case managers
  • Bilingual services: Fully fluent English and Spanish communication at every stage
  • Transparency: Clear explanations of your case, options, and realistic expectations
  • Availability: We\'re here when you need us, including emergency situations
  • Compassion: We understand you\'re going through a difficult time and treat you with respect and empathy
  • Aggressive advocacy: We fight tirelessly for maximum compensation while insurance companies fight to minimize payouts
  • Over 300 five-star Google reviews from satisfied clients
  • Millions recovered for injured victims across the Rio Grande Valley
  • Proven trial experience in Cameron County District Court
  • Successful outcomes in complex cases involving catastrophic injuries
  • Strong reputation among judges, opposing counsel, and the legal community

We have the resources to handle even the most complex personal injury cases:

  • Network of expert witnesses across multiple specialties
  • Advanced technology for case presentation and trial graphics
  • Financial resources to advance case costs during litigation
  • Relationships with medical providers who work on lien arrangements
  • Investigative capabilities to thoroughly document liability and damages

As a local firm with offices throughout South Texas, we\’re invested in this community:

  • We live here and raise our families here
  • We understand the challenges facing Rio Grande Valley residents
  • We're committed to making our community safer by holding negligent parties accountable
  • We support local organizations and give back to the community we serve
  • Personal attention: You'll work directly with experienced attorneys, not paralegals or case managers
  • Bilingual services: Fully fluent English and Spanish communication at every stage
  • Transparency: Clear explanations of your case, options, and realistic expectations
  • Availability: We\'re here when you need us, including emergency situations
  • Compassion: We understand you\'re going through a difficult time and treat you with respect and empathy
  • Aggressive advocacy: We fight tirelessly for maximum compensation while insurance companies fight to minimize payouts
  • Over 300 five-star Google reviews from satisfied clients
  • Millions recovered for injured victims across the Rio Grande Valley
  • Proven trial experience in Cameron County District Court
  • Successful outcomes in complex cases involving catastrophic injuries
  • Strong reputation among judges, opposing counsel, and the legal community

We have the resources to handle even the most complex personal injury cases:

  • Network of expert witnesses across multiple specialties
  • Advanced technology for case presentation and trial graphics
  • Financial resources to advance case costs during litigation
  • Relationships with medical providers who work on lien arrangements
  • Investigative capabilities to thoroughly document liability and damages

As a local firm with offices throughout South Texas, we\’re invested in this community:

  • We live here and raise our families here
  • We understand the challenges facing Rio Grande Valley residents
  • We're committed to making our community safer by holding negligent parties accountable
  • We support local organizations and give back to the community we serve

Contact Kenny Perez Law Today

Don’t let insurance companies take advantage of you. Don’t accept less than you deserve. Don’t face this challenge alone.

Spain Flag Hablamos Español – Llame hoy para una consulta gratuita

Your recovery is our priority. Your justice is our mission. Let our experience, resources, and commitment to the Rio Grande Valley community work for you.

We're available 24/7 for urgent matters.
Kenny Perez
300+ Google Reviews
$75M+ recovered
Bilingual Attorney
Form for Brownsville Car Accident Lawyer Page
Free Case Review

No obligation and no fee unless we win for you.

Scroll to Top